About Us

Your Commissary and Exchange Benefits are in Jeopardy

Recent activities by Congress threaten to eliminate the saving you get when you shop at the Commissary. If passed, these actions could also significantly reduce the money set aside to pay for MWR (Morale, Welfare, and Recreations) activities for military families.

How could this happen? In an environment focused on reducing the deficit, law makers must cut expenses from the budget before agreeing to pay for new programs. Why does this affect the commissary? Unlike other grocery stores, the commissary does not make a profit. By law, commissaries can only charge consumers 5% more than the item costs to stock the shelves. This unique pricing allows military families to save more than 30% on their grocery bill. This works because the costs to operate the commissary is paid by a subsidy in the federal budget.

Earlier this year, the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee voted to eliminate the federal subsidy for military commissaries and recommended the Department of Defense (DoD)consolidate the operations of the commissaries and exchanges in order to pay for the Caring for Camp Lejeune Veterans Act of 2011 (S.277). We strongly believe these families’ health care needs must be met, but we are adamantly opposed to doing so at the expense of other military families. There is still time to act. This bill still needs to be voted on by the entire Senate and then approved by the House, but it poses a very real threat.
Senator Tom Coburn’s (R-OK) “Back to Black” report also calls for consolidating military commissaries and exchangesinto a single, nonsubsidized retail system over five years.
There is growing concern that the $1.3 billion subsidy to operate the commissary will be targeted by the Joint Committee on Deficit Reduction or “super committee” tasked to find at least $1.2 trillion in savings over the next decade.

If this bill is passed, prices in the commissary and exchanges will go up in order to make up for the loss of federal funds. You’ve told us how important your commissaries and exchanges are, especially those of you who live overseas or in remote locations, and we’ve shared your thoughts with Congress. You can also tell Congress what you think. Share your story at www.saveourbenefit.com.

If the additional step to consolidate the behind the scenes operations of the commissaries and exchanges takes place, the $300 million earned to pay for MWR programs that support critical quality of life programs could go away. In 2006, after spending $17 million to study the issue, the Department of Defense determined that consolidation was not the answer to budget concerns. It wasn’t the answer then and it is not the answer now.

For more information on the Commissary benefit, we suggest you read Tom Philpott’s article, Commissary boss: Critics overlook the efficiencies. We have also provided a list of important facts on the commissary and exchange.

Important Facts:

Military families currently save an average of 31% by shopping in the Commissary.
Military families save an average of over 20% by shopping in the Exchanges.
The commissaries and exchanges pay $800 million to more than 50,000 military family members employed by them.
Exchanges generate $300 million in dividends which are used to support Morale, Welfare and Recreation (MWR) programs for service members and military families.
For the $1.5 billion spent annually, commissaries and exchanges generate $5.6 billion in savings.

We urge you to let Congress know how much you value your Commissary and Exchange Benefit! Please leave your comment below.

Comments

Thanks for submitting your feedback. If your comment is personal in nature, please email info@MilitaryFamily.org.

Items 101 - 150 of 354

Comment: It would drasticly effect our family if the BX & Commissary were to increase their prices. Military life is difficult and you must provide families benefits to keep them fighting the good fight. If families are worried about bills sevicemen and women will find it difficult to be focused at work not to mention the lowering of morale.
Submitted by: Hope on November 26, 2011

Comment: I don't understand why you would eliminate a benefit that actually employs people and makes good sense commercially?? There are thousands of other programs to look into that are not self sustaining. Go find real waste, that is what we elect you people to do. Leave this one alone. Military families deserve this "benefit".
Submitted by: Navywife on November 24, 2011

Comment: i am not in the military, but my boyfriend is, i believe that this is such a horrible ideah.. i am sadden on how america shows our military men and women how much they appreciate our freedom. the ONLY REASON YOU are able to even vote for this, and have the freedom to choose is because of them. the sacrifice many people make to join and serve is not fair.. i have not seen my boyfriend in over 8 months i miss him so much. the sacrifices people make to not see there families. people that cannot come home for the holidays. and yet take away there benifits? less people would want to join the military, or shop at the commissary. put yourselfs in there shoes, and realize what you are doing.i doubt they all want to lose there freedom so we can have ours and not have any benifits. its not fair. it sadens me. take away some money from the rich. where all they buy is expensive cloths, shoes. purses.. and the military families is just survive.. some with out ther spouses for months. and to buy food for there children because there husbands or wifes are not home to support you.. think twice america..
Submitted by: women on November 23, 2011

Comment: please leave our benefits alone. we sacrifice so muc already.
Submitted by: hil on November 22, 2011

Comment: As a reservist I lose a big part of my civilian salary when deployed or on active duty. Shopping at the commissary is a great benefit that helps lessen the burden on my family as they deal with a loss in income while I serve. The commissary is a huge benefit that all military families rely on and should be left alone.
Submitted by: Boomer on November 22, 2011

Comment: Clearly our congressional represenatives have already forgoten the sacrafices of the servicemen\women and more over their dependants. This act is not responsible and does not represent the interest of those that serve to protect this nation. I would hope that a dedicated congressional represenative would have the moral fortitude to stand up to specail interest and represent our Military families.
Submitted by: on November 22, 2011

Comment: I'm a Marine Gunnery Sergeant with 17 years in and 2 kids. I shop at the commissary because it saves me time and money even though it doesn't carry the variety and supply that off-base retailers do. AAFES and DECA are 2 different organizations and AAFES is run poorly. If the commissary is combined with AAFES, everyone will lose, including the taxpayer. The subsidy paid for the commissaries is a tiny cost for the taxpayer to pay for the American defense establishment. I say cut costs at AAFES facilities and MWR programs on bases that are near large metro areas and only provide them at isolated bases.
Submitted by: Malcom, on November 22, 2011

Comment: Being able to buy nutricious food at a reasonable price at the commissary is critical to families. If there wasn't such a price savings then many would opt to eat fast food every day and then our health care costs would rise. The 31% saved at commissaries help. The exchanges are tied to the local community prices and even though the statistics say you save 20% I do not believe it. Even with the no tax benefit it is cheaper to buy things at WalMart or Amazon (with the exception of high end items offered at MEX). If you combine the commissary and exchange there will be mismanagement, overhead will go higher, the food selection and quality will go down and we will have no cost savings. Keep the federal subsidy for commissaries and do not combine them with the exchanges! Furthermore, do not combine AAFES with NEX or the Marine Corps Exchange. The quality of items at AAFES sucks compared with Navy/Marine Exchanges, but all serve their own military communities well.
Submitted by: Hawaii Families on November 22, 2011

Comment: Do not eliminate the federal subsidy for military commissaries.
Submitted by: Dani on November 22, 2011

Comment: It seams to me that this government always wants to take away military benetits and we are the service mambers who put our lives on the line every day for YOU. If you cut all the pork out of the budget then YOU IN CONGRESS can leave our benefits alone and still balance the budget. This of course will not help YOU get reelected because the PORK YOU spread around YOUR DIISTRECT HELPS and we the military can't help YOU that way. STOP BALANCING THE BUDGET ON THE BACKS OF THOSE WHO PROTECT YOU EVERY DAY. Please look some were else and leave our commissary and exchanges alone. They are a great part of our benefits.
Submitted by: hugh06 on November 22, 2011

Comment: Let's stop the insanity of digging in the military, our benefits, and let us remember, there are many people in the world who mean us harm and want us to fail... taking cuts in the military will enable their efforts. Defense is the key to all other program success, and we can't do it right without a volunteer force. Taking benefits will impact our ability to sustain the all volunteer force. The volunteer force is what makes us so different.
Submitted by: Rangermp25 on November 22, 2011

Comment: Lots of military families depend on the savings at the commissary to provide nutritious meals for their families. Many of us do not qualify for assistance such as food stamps, however our military pay is barley enough to make ends meet. This dilemma is compounded when spouses have to leave jobs to relocate with the member. Why make it more difficult for military families? Our country depends on the our members, but how can they focus on their jobs when their families are in debt and starving?
Submitted by: Coast Guard Wife on November 22, 2011

Comment: Taking away this privilege will only hurt the military since those, especially E-6 and below, on Active Duty barely make the equivalent of minimum wage. Sure there is BAH (meant to offset housing), Subsistence (meant to offset meals), and Tri-Care (in jeopardy as well) but, take these away and the Active Duty individual doesn’t even make minimum wage.
Submitted by: Guardsman on November 22, 2011

Comment: Taking away our AAFES and DECA benefits will put military families in deeper financial jeopardy! Military members get paid less than minimum wage and with operation tempos still going strong and the downturn in the economy, spouses can't find jobs that help support the family AND pay for childcare.
Submitted by: Military Families in Jeopardy on November 22, 2011

Comment: The commissary and the exchange provide stable pricing to military families and allow us some certainty in a very uncertain world of spouses deploying and being in very real danger. These benefits are one of the factors that go into deciding to "stay in" or not. If congress keeps threatening (and perhaps really does) to take away retirements. medical, and now our commissary I can honestly say that when my husband's commitment is up we will not be signing back on for another tour.....it's just not worth it. The job is hard enough without having your own Congress essentially spit in your face by sending the message that your service is nothing and you don't deserve the extra benefits. Shame on Congress, and shame on the American people as a whole who still don't get it that our country is at WAR.
Submitted by: NavyFamilyoffive on November 22, 2011

Comment: I just urge you not to take away these privilege that we have earn over the years. It would affect the lives of so many. Look to get more from the rich people in the US.
Submitted by: Jesse Jay on November 22, 2011

Comment: Commissary, PX, and MWR are basic benefits which extend the quality of life for the military. The Commissary and PX extends the purchasing power of military families allow them to cover essential needs. MWR allow military families more than just recreation, it allows them much needed down time to regroup and reenergize. Altering or eliminating these benefits from us will cost the country more in the end where morale will plunge, and unhappy military personnel are distracted personnel who will leave the service; and recruitment will become a much more difficult task. The members of Congress enjoy a variety of exclusive benefits. Our military personnel and their families deserve no less.
Submitted by: Army Wife on November 22, 2011

Comment: Being the father of a career soldier who has dedicated his life to our country I find it hard to believe that the congress of the United States is trying to kill the the military benefits of our protectors. If some of the fat hogs sucking on the teat of the nation would lop off some of the perks and do-nothings in the house and senate and a few of the presidential aides there would be plenty enough to keep these benefits.If congress was to meet every other year and limit them to two terms, knock off the congressional pensions and have them contribute to 401K's like the common fodder, think of the savings.
Submitted by: bluto on November 22, 2011

Comment: We are an enlisted family of 4. Congress know's that we barely make any money as it is. If it wasn't for the commissary I wouldn't be able to stretch my dollar as much as I can. All the local stores,Even walmart is too darned expensive! If you want to cut something how about looking at your own pay first!!
Submitted by: Samantha on November 21, 2011

Comment: Please do not allow these cuts to be made. As military families, we rely on the savings received at the commissaries, especially when living in areas where the cost of groceries is astronomical.
Submitted by: Leah on November 21, 2011

Comment: It's sad to know that I fought for this country because I love being free....the Army says "FREEDOM ISN'T FREE" So I guess this is how those who served get repaid! Such sadness!
Submitted by: Keep Military Benefits on November 21, 2011

Comment: leave the military benefits alone. We give not only our life, but that of being with our family to keep america safe. Our benefits are worth that to all or you, even you who sit in congress and seem to be doing nothing.
Submitted by: airdale143 on November 21, 2011

Comment: As a family of 6, it would be very difficult for us to afford groceries if we didn't have the commissary to rely on. I have tried shopping at other stores but it just costs too much. Please stop trying to take benefits away from military families. We already deal with enough without worrying if we will be able to feed our children.
Submitted by: armywife on November 21, 2011

Comment: The commissary and the exchange are important to us as it is hard for us to afford to buy groceries and other items off post. When we lived in Hawaii, there would have been no way we would have survived if we ddn't have these services. We shop almost exclusively the commissary and if possible, the exchange.
Submitted by: huhnerhaus on November 21, 2011

Comment: PLEASE think twice before u do this to the military families. Service members do not need to worry about whether their spouses or children will have what they need or whether their families are going to bed hungry as they go off to war or maneuvers. These are benefits that most lower ranking military personnel and thier families rely on to make it from pay day to pay day. If our Military is to remain strong we must not put any extra burdens on the family by taking away these precious benefits.
Submitted by: military wife on November 21, 2011

Comment: Please, (in the name of all that is decent and right!) Do not touch the commissary\exchange benefits! Surely this is one area which really helps us military families to have a quality of life above POVERTY levels! I am sure that our members of congress could afford to pay for their own health insurance. Why don't we use the funds used to pay for their health insurance and put THAT $ towards Caring for Camp Lejeune Veterans act?
Submitted by: mzmom on November 21, 2011

Comment: I cannot believe that any military benefits should be touched at all!! What these soldiers do for our country is something you do not find in other countries. These soldiers are not paid enough at all and should be given much more in perks in benefits from the government and their community so STOP touching the military if we want to continue to see strong military support and more young men and women to sign into the military.
Submitted by: ma on November 21, 2011

Comment: Please leave the exchanges and the commissaries alone. Military families, especially the enlisted, the junior officers and those deployed overseas or to remote areas, need these benefits to continue to insure their families' quality of life. Please show that you care about the quality of life for those in the military who are putting their lives on the line for the benefit af all Americans.
Submitted by: Janie on November 21, 2011

Comment: how dare you even consider this? you in the congress and senate vote yourself full medical benefits and substantial raises while the rest of the "working class" is scraping to get by, now you`re considering removing benefits from the very people who risk and give their lives so you can carry on. SHAME ON YOU.
Submitted by: al b on November 21, 2011

Comment: As a military family we need the savings we can get from the commissary and exchange. Our Airmen and Soldiers don't get paid super well and we need to save every penny in every way we can to get by.
Submitted by: Lara on November 21, 2011

Comment: My commissary benefit has helped me make ends meet over the years. Should our military families, who sacrifice so much for our country, really have to stand in line at food pantries. It's a sad day when our government won't support those who help make our way of life possible.
Submitted by: military mom/spouse on November 21, 2011

Comment: As a military spouse who has been faced with difficulties finding employment due to moving, shopping at commissariesand saving money is crucial. It is a benefit that I value tremendously and am grateful for. Some military families may find making ends meet when it comes to putting food on their tables and caring for their family if it were not for military commissaries and exchanges.
Submitted by: RP on November 21, 2011

Comment: We military families don't make very much money to begin with. We are sent to all different places of the world, and live with a lot of hard times to protect and serve our country. Removing our Commissary benefits would be an additional hardship, and would be like taking food out of our families' mouths
Submitted by: ZPAD on November 21, 2011

Comment: Please do not eliminate our benefits for the Commisary and Exchage. Military families have been already sacrificed enough, like to lose those benefits that have been helping us a lot to survive financially. It's no fair for us, after they have been fighting for our country.
Submitted by: Military wife on November 21, 2011

Comment: I think for all that the men and women of the military give, Congress can find a better avenue to cut costs. Try cutting back on benfits for those who don't work at all; much less work for everyone else in America to live free.
Submitted by: Loving the Commisary on November 21, 2011

Comment: Please keep our benefits for the Commissary and Exchange. They are both valuable for our families to survive. Thank you
Submitted by: JAN on November 21, 2011

Comment: I COUNT on my NEX and Commissary as part of our compensation pkg after 30 yrs of service. Do NOT change the game rules after we have already lived up to our end of the bargain!
Submitted by: Mrs. Haas on November 21, 2011

Comment: It's terrible that these benefits are in jeopardy. I have given up so many jobs because of military moves or stressful deployments. It is very difficult to pack up and move and find a new job that will pay you as much as your last. We make so many sacrifices as military families and we all depend on the commissary to help us get by until the next pay day.
Submitted by: marinewife0311 on November 21, 2011

Comment: I use the Commissary and Exchange all the time, more so than shopping in any local stores. We would not be able to entertain with our staff and families as we do if I had to pay the prices in the grocery stores...this includes volunteer recognition luncheons and other team building efforts. I agree that everyone should not have to pay for one specific group as with the Camp Lejeune Veterans Act...there is no argument that they deserve some help...but to penalize everyone else in jobs and savings and funding is not ethical.
Submitted by: CT on November 21, 2011

Comment: This is basically a pay cut. Most of us are on an enlisted salary, which is not large when you're talking about supporting a family. We already struggle to make ends meet and now another cut. The politicians are always willing to have a photo-op with some form of the military to show their "support," however the proof is in what you do, not what you say. If this bill is passed, they will be telling military families, "We do not appreciate the sacrifices you already make. We would rather take your money/benefit and give it to someone else." That really hurts. I understand that times are difficult and cuts have to be made, but couldn't they limit the amount they give to strange research grants or foreign aid to China or something? I just don't understand. They always say they care and support military families. How they vote on this bill will be the proof of whether they do or do not. The military can be a powerful voting block if we'll just do a little research. Check your senator & representative's voting record on this and vote accordingly. Maybe then they'll get the message.
Submitted by: adc3 on November 21, 2011

Comment: Shopping at the Comissary is integral to our ability to set aside amounts of money for our emergency fund and investment in our retirement and the schooling of our two young children. Without the discount that we receive by buying groceries at the commissary, not only would I have to sacrifice some quality for quantity of food that I'm able to purchase (if I shopped at a retail store as opposed to the Comissary), but I don't see a way to continue to establish an emergency fund or invest in our IRA and 529 plans on an E-4 salary without the 30% savings. Please don't cut funding for our Comissaries! They are an integral part of the lives of military families - we are already all sacrificing so much by sharing our loved ones with the military - please don't make it harder on us!
Submitted by: Coast Guard Family of 4 on November 21, 2011

Comment: Congressmen are already making noise about cutting SNAP, which some military families depend on, and now this??? This is outrageous! Don't military families already sacrifice enough?
Submitted by: on November 21, 2011

Comment: Find another way to pay your bills Congress!! Stop cutting military benefits. It is so wrong to hurt the ones who give you the freedoms to do so!!
Submitted by: army_wife_and_mom on November 21, 2011

Comment: I'm not sure how we'll eat if they pass this. If it wasn't for commissary prices, I don't think we could afford groceries.
Submitted by: Danisty on November 21, 2011

Comment: If this bill goes through, the commissary is not going to get the shoppers it has currently. Once this bill is complete, MCCS will have their hand in the commissary funds and this will eliminate any discounts we had prior when the efficient DeCa ran it. I, for one, WILL NOT shop at the commissary any longer, as I will get better prices by shopping at multiple grocery stores in town and using coupons and grocery store discount cards.
Submitted by: cdevaul on November 21, 2011

Comment: The only way we can afford our groceries and household items is by purchassing them through the commissary and exchange. It seems incomprehensible that Congress can send our spouses in harm's way but cannot protect the families who remain at home. Perhaps Congress should listen to the people of the military before they act.
Submitted by: Concerned Mom of Four on November 21, 2011

Comment: Please consider how you are honoring military service this month, the month of the military family. Lawmakers are quick to say that they appreciate the service of military members and the sacrifices their families make but ultimately this is nothing more than lip service.Please protect our comissary benefits. Help us keep food on the table while our spouses serve.
Submitted by: Proud Military Spouse on November 21, 2011

Comment: What a horrible idea. Unless you're planning on bumping every sailor, airman, soldier's pay by the offset in savings don't even consider this plan.
Submitted by: Catherine S on November 21, 2011

Items 101 - 150 of 354